Showing posts with label Dr. Kalthoff. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Dr. Kalthoff. Show all posts

Tuesday, October 13, 2026

Christopher Columbus

Christopher Columbus has been turned into a whipping boy, a villain, and it has been fashionable since the 500th anniversary in 1992. Rather than being celebrated as an explorer, he was instead seen as some rank imperialist who was doing all he could, essentially, to rape, pillage, spread disease, and enslave people, and that's what you hear today. Recently, the Wall Street Journal ran an article pushing back, called Straight Talk About Christopher Columbus.

Dr. Mark Kalthoff, Professor and Chairman of the Department of History at Hillsdale College, gave a rather intriguing interview discussing European and American history. He says that in the late 15th and early 16th centuries, the world wasn't a particularly tolerant or friendly place by many of the standards we appreciate today. Europeans themselves were looking to the West to travel across the Atlantic to get to the East because they couldn't go the short way, which was to turn back to go East because there were all these Muslims and Moors who were in their way. It turns out that wherever you went, the stronger people in the world made the weaker people suffer.
So, in Columbus' time, the Muslims and the Chinese were much more powerful than the poor Europeans, and as a result, Europeans were suffering; they were being enslaved, and millions died from plagues that were brought to them from farther East. The world of the 15th and 16th centuries was one in which powerful people routinely subjugated weaker people. We didn't have modern medicine, so disease killed people, and slavery was rampant the world over. The exceptional thing about Columbus isn't that he didn't do those things; he did some of those things, and so did everyone else.
The more exceptional thing was that, over time, the ideas he spread and those who followed in his wake in Christendom and Western Europe were the home of the place that gradually exterminated slavery. Gradually began to share ideas about free trade and express ideas of tolerance. This idea of tolerance, and being willing not just to say might makes right, is itself a Western idea that grew out of the civilization Columbus came from.
In some sense, he was a product of his time. But that doesn't make him the one to demonize. Let's understand the late 15th and early 16th centuries, and see whether European practices, as they traveled to North America, were particularly different from how Europeans were treated by, say, Muslims, Chinese, or others they might encounter.
One of the greatest temptations for students of history, and the highest responsibility for good professors, is to recognize that we are all living now and have concerns about our day and our age. Many of them are legitimate and understandable. But the job of the historian and honest student of history is not to take those high-minded views we have come to accept as normative in our day and sniff around the past to find who either exceeded or failed to live up to our standards of normative excellence.
But instead, try to understand the past and what circumstances, ideas, and events made it possible for people to hold ideas that seem foreign to us today, ideas that were once high and noble, that we have forgotten to cling to and need to relearn. In other cases, we have overcome obstacles that tripped up previous generations.
We are alive today; we're better than those who came before; therefore, we are entitled to judge them. C.S. Lewis called that outlook "chronological snobbery." The idea is that those who are further down the timeline are, by virtue of that process, more enlightened. That notion is also called presentism. That doesn't help much because it assumes that what we are doing now is better than what we did before, just because we're doing it now. It can justify a move to bad policy and a kind of presentist hubris we want to avoid.

-Dr. Mark Kalthoff

Monday, January 9, 2023

Christianity and Science

One of the fascinating things about the scientific revolution is that when you look at the luminaries of the events of the late 16th but mostly the 17th century, you come up with names of people like Galileo, Isaac Newton, Robert Boyle, Rene Descartes, Johannes Kepler, and the list goes on. These are names that even schoolchildren bumped into when they studied an outline of the Western European intellectual history of science. These are all people who were deeply committed Christians. If it's the case of the scientific revolution meant reason letting go of religion, it would be odd to set that up in such a way when many of the leaders themselves saw themselves doing God's work.

Take, for example, Kepler, who himself was a Lutheran. He originally thought he would be a Lutheran minister, and he went to seminary but ended up instead going the route of mathematics and astronomy. He was thrilled later on in his life when he came up with his law of planetary motion that his work was being useful; he said, "I originally thought that I would become a preacher seeing that I can glorify God and do God's work this way I'm happy to see myself effectively reading the book of nature."

One of the prevailing metaphors was the metaphor of God's two books, in which he reveals Himself through His words and His works. Many of the scientists of the scientific revolution saw themselves as an exegesis of nature and that they were reading the handy work of God and laying it bare as they were seeking to recover the lost knowledge Adam once had.

Isaac Newton actually wrote more on theology than he did on science. If you took a pile and stacked up all his theological musings, he was particularly interested in Old Testament prophecy. He wrote more about theology and speculated upon the divine and his natural philosophy than he did in his comparably briefer scientific works.

Robert Boyle, one of the leaders of modern chemistry, was very much concerned with doing his science as an exercise in natural theology, showing God was a designer who reveals His own power, wisdom, and attributes in His book of nature.

-Dr.Mark Kalthoff

Monday, December 26, 2022

Galileo

Chances are you have been taught some of the same things I was taught in history or even perhaps science class about why the Roman Catholic Church had Galileo arrested. The myth goes something like this: Galileo was imprisoned or somehow tortured by the Church for advocating Copernicanism, that model of the universe that was relatively new at his time, firmly establishing the church's eternal enemy of science.

The Galileo affair is and has been until recent generations of a profession of historians of science today have come to a much better understanding of Galileo than you might have found 50 or 100 years ago. The story is often told that Galileo was some type of champion of free thought and some kind of point man for the scientific community, who turns his telescope to heaven and sees error reputable evidence somehow that proves the earth moves and the sun stands still. And the Church, ruffled by this for fear it contradicts their cherished understanding of Scripture, does all it can to silence him, including threatening him with jail or torture or, in fact, putting him in jail and torturing him. The truth really couldn't be further from this.
First of all, Galileo thought he had this positive evidence of the earth's motion and proof of the Copernican Hypothesis, but his evidence was faulty. He grounded most of his confidence in a theory he had about the tides. Although he thought it was a good theory, it turns out that it really wasn't a good theory. He did have interesting telescopical observations, but the telescopical observations themselves stop short of demonstrating that the earth moved. They certainly showed problems with one of the leading competitive theories of Claudius Ptolemaeus, the second-century astronomer. But Galileo overstated his case. He did so in a context where he alienated himself not so much from the Church as from the leading natural philosophers as we would call scientists in those days. Many of them had independent arguments with Galileo over the behavior of falling bodies, floating bodies in the water, sun spots, and how to interpret a supernova, and in case after case, Galileo was at odds with many of the leaders of the scientific community. When they found themselves frustrated by his virtuosity in these arguments, they began to involve the Church and challenge his robust claims to the motion of the earth.
Leaders of the Church were certainly open to the prospect that the earth might move, but they wanted to see good evidence. One of the most important leading figures, Cardinal Robert Bellarmine was pretty clear; he said, "if there was a true demonstration that the sun is at the center of the world, I like to see that demonstration. But I can't believe there is such a demonstration until someone shows it to me." He was not persuaded by what Galileo had to show him about the tides.
So Galileo kind of dug himself into a hole and did so even further when he was enjoined not to teach or publically discuss this idea of the earth's motion, and instead, he went ahead and wrote his dialog on The Two Cheif World Systems, which he published in 1632. It was a dialog between generally three figures, and in the mouth of the fool, he put the words of the Pope. When it was pointed out to the Pope that Galileo was actually taking this opportunity to what appeared to be ridiculing the Pope, Galileo was summoned to Rome and put on trial.
Ultimately, he was found vehemently suspected of heresy; in other words, he was never officially charged as a heretic but was placed under house arrest in his comfortable Italian villa for the remainder of his days which he continued scientific work. So the story is much more interesting than the narrow one that makes it look like the church was anti-intellect and bigoted. The point here is while he did have his opponents in his theory about the motion of heavenly bodies and the place of the sun and earth, these opponents were largely in the natural science communities and not within the Church itself.

-Dr. Mark Kalthoff

Christopher Columbus

Christopher Columbus has been turned into a whipping boy, a villain, and it has been fashionable since the 500th anniversary in 1992. Rather...